Saturday, October 18, 2008

Communication Problems

So it's been my first week of work. To begin with, we're working with the Direction de la Méthode de la Planification (DMP). In two weeks' time they have to publish the Programme d’Appui au Développement de l’Economie, du Commerce et de l’Industrie (PADECI) and the Plan de Travail (PTA) 2009 which set out the Activities, Action Plan, Indicators, Budget, Responsibilities and Timeline for each Programme within the Ministry. The PADECI is divided into two sections - Private Sector and Governance & Economy; the PTA is divided into five sections - Administration, Economy, Trade, Industry and Regional. These documents set out exactly how the Ministry is going to fulfill its objectives in the Madagascar Action Plan (MAP), which is itself divided into 8 sections, each with several subsections (challenges, indicators etc), covering the same ground as many components of the PTA and PADECI, which in turn incorporate many aspects of the MAP, but not according to any predictable pattern. These reports are then guided by the Politique Général de l’Etat (PGE), and their progress is monitored by the Système National Intégré de Suivi et Evaluation (SNISE). Follow?

So on Tuesday we meet with the DMP to discuss how best to go about finishing these reports. In the next two weeks. So they ask us for any ideas we might have and give us past copies of the PADECI, PGE, PTA and SNISE to look at. Thursday morning we meet again. Four hours later we have almost agreed on a Note Conceptuelle - a plan for how we are going to go about studying these reports. These things clearly take time. We agree to read them, talk about them, analyse them, then try to improve them. We also have to agree on a chronologie - Monday we will read the reports, Tuesday we will talk about them... DMP then leave to write up the Note.

We see if for the first time the next day. It is five pages of utter incomprehensibility (“Une analyse multi-critères des actions possibles en fonction de leur adéquation à la stratégie selon les mêmes objectifs considérés alors comme critères d’appréciation...”). We must then meet with UNDP for their approval. They remove everything bar the first page. Next week the Note goes to the Department heads. Following that, we can actually start working – we will have spent a week planning the planning…

Forgive the descent into development policy wonkishness, but the degree of planning that is required before anything gets done sometimes beggars belief. Easterly compared ‘planners’ to ‘searchers’ - and this week has been a shining example of ‘planners’ winning out. There are targets set for the number of Madagascans in the London Olympics, the growth rate of the artisan sector over the next five years and the number of tourists by 2012 (which, by the way, is going to be a long-shot unless people start coming to visit me). All of these plans ‘assume’ a growth rate of 8%, but don’t really explain where that might be coming from.

But this is how it’s done. Things move slowly and must be discussed, at length. It can make for a pretty frustrating work process. There’s clearly a communication barrier, not so much in terms of language, but more content. The status quo is very entrenched; I don’t know why, but it reminds me of Mrs Richards, in Fawlty Towers, who refuses to turn her hearing aid on because “it wears down the batteries”.

No comments:

Post a Comment